Straight Off the Reheat Card
How to Store
Homemade Cookies
Sealed tight. 3 days on the counter, 3 months in the freezer. When you want one warm again, 350°F for 4 to 5 minutes brings the melt back. That is the whole answer. The rest of this page is why it works and how to get it right every time.
This is the card we hand out at pickup, written out long.
The Melt Comes Back
How to Reheat Cookies
Three ways. Pick by how much time you have.
| Method | Temperature | Time | The Tip |
|---|---|---|---|
| The Oven | 350°F | 4 to 5 min | Middle rack, straight on the sheet. Crisp edges, gooey middle. |
| The Microwave | No oven needed | 10 to 15 sec | One cookie, one plate. Stop at warm. You want melty, not molten. |
| From Frozen | 350°F | 5 to 7 min | Straight from the freezer to the oven. No thawing, no waiting. |
The Oven, Step by Step
Heat the oven to 350°F.
Set the cookies straight on the sheet.
Middle rack.
4 to 5 minutes. From frozen, 5 to 7.
Pull them. Crisp edges, gooey middle.
Fair warning: warm ones disappear even faster.
Keep Them Fresh
Why Sealed Tight Is the Whole Game
Cookies go stale two ways. They dry out, or they pull moisture in from the air and go soft in all the wrong places. Airtight stops both. That is the entire reason the card says sealed tight and not just covered.
Cool them completely first. A warm cookie under a lid steams, the steam turns to water, and the water lands on your cookies. Give them the time, then seal them.
Ours are made with grass-fed butter, real vanilla, and real chocolate. Worth protecting. Start with the Chocolate Chip Cookie.
Do Not Refrigerate
The refrigerator dries cookies out. It is the one place on this page we will tell you not to put them. Counter for 3 days. Freezer for anything longer. Nothing in between.
Can You Freeze Cookies? Yes.
How to Freeze Cookies
Cool Them Completely
No shortcuts on this one. A warm cookie sealed up steams, and that steam turns to water on your cookies.
Seal Them Airtight
A freezer bag with the air pressed out, or a container with a lid that actually closes. Airtight is the whole game.
Freeze
Up to 3 months. Label the bag if you are the type. We are not.
Reheat Straight From Frozen
350°F, 5 to 7 minutes, middle rack. No thawing, no waiting. The melt comes back.
A batch of 6 rarely needs the freezer. We are not judging.
The card works better with cookies.
Chocolate Chip · Cinnamon Roll · $4.25 each · Batches of 6 · Pickup at Kierland Commons
Free Cookie Inside
Join the List
New flavors. Limited drops. Fresh out of the oven.
Sign up and get a free cookie on your first order.